Human vs. Machine: Striking the Balance in Crafting Analytical Essays


Have you ever wondered about the role of technology in essay writing, particularly when it comes to crafting an exceptional analytical essay? With the rise of automated essay grading systems, the landscape of writing assessments is rapidly evolving. However, striking the right balance between human and machine involvement is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the writing process. In this article, we will explore the benefits and limitations of automated essay grading systems, the importance of human feedback and assessment, the impact of technology on writing skills, and propose an ideal approach for achieving a harmonious coexistence between humans and machines in crafting analytical essay.

The Rise of Automated Essay Grading Systems

Automated essay grading systems have gained significant popularity in educational institutions. These systems utilize artificial intelligence algorithms to evaluate essays based on various criteria such as grammar, structure, and content. The benefits of automated grading include quick feedback, consistency, and scalability. However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations and potential drawbacks of relying solely on machines. Automated systems may struggle with nuanced or creative writing, and their evaluation may lack the depth of human insight.

The Role of Human Feedback and Assessment

While machines offer efficiency, the importance of human feedback in essay writing cannot be undermined. Human assessment provides subjective evaluation and personalized guidance tailored to individual students' needs. Human feedback allows for a deeper understanding of students' thought processes and encourages critical thinking skills. By offering constructive criticism, educators can help students develop their writing skills in a way that automated systems cannot replicate.

The Impact of Technology on Writing Skills

The integration of technology in writing has undoubtedly influenced the development of writing skills. While technology can enhance certain aspects, concerns arise when students overly rely on machines for writing tasks. The risk of sacrificing critical thinking and the ability to convey complex ideas arises when technology becomes a crutch. Balancing technological assistance with the cultivation of analytical thinking and writing proficiency is essential for producing well-rounded and competent writers.

Striking the Balance: The Ideal Approach

To strike the perfect balance, a hybrid model of human and machine involvement in essay writing can be adopted. Automated grading systems can serve as valuable tools for efficiency and feedback. They can quickly identify surface-level errors and provide immediate feedback to students. However, it is equally important to leverage human assessment for subjective evaluation and tailored guidance. Educators can offer insights, address individual strengths and weaknesses, and encourage creativity in writing that automated systems might miss.

The Future of Essay Writing: Collaboration and Coexistence

As technology continues to advance, the future of essay writing holds exciting possibilities. Collaborative efforts between humans and machines can lead to improved writing outcomes. Machines can assist in evaluating essays efficiently, while humans bring their expertise in providing comprehensive feedback. Adapting to technological advancements and embracing them without sacrificing essential writing skills is vital for the future of essay writing.


Finding the right balance between human and machine involvement in essay writing is paramount. By recognizing the benefits and limitations of automated essay grading systems, valuing human feedback, and striking a harmonious coexistence between humans and machines, we can foster the growth of competent writers. It is crucial for students to consider their own approach to essay writing, embracing the advantages of technology while maintaining critical thinking skills and the art of expression.
Remember, essay writing is a multifaceted skill that requires both the efficiency of machines and the human touch to truly excel.

The University of Kansas prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, ethnicity, religion, sex, national origin, age, ancestry, disability, status as a veteran, sexual orientation, marital status, parental status, gender identity, gender expression and genetic information in the University’s programs and activities. The following person has been designated to handle inquiries regarding the non-discrimination policies: Director of the Office of Institutional Opportunity and Access.